Does chicken soup really help fight a cold?

41
729

We all know the grandmotherly wisdom of serving chicken soup to someone with a cold, but does this particular meal really have medicinal properties? Could slurping up chicken soup save me a trip to the local pharmacy?

You won’t find studies in humans that prove chicken soup can fight a cold, but there’s enough evidence to make it worth trying.

One study published in the medical journal Chest suggested that chicken soup might have anti-inflammatory effects, which could possibly ease symptoms of upper respiratory tract infections.

Researchers specifically studied the movement of neutrophils — a type of white blood cell — when combined with soup. They found that the movement of neutrophils was reduced in the presence of soup, suggesting a possible anti-inflammatory mechanism that could at least theoretically alleviate cold symptoms. Or not.

“There are substances (in chicken soup) that could affect cells in the body, that could potentially have medicinal effects, but whether they are good or bad for you, we didn’t test,” said study author Dr. Stephen Rennard, Larson professor of medicine at the University of Nebraska Medical Center in Omaha.

Because the study was done in a laboratory and not in humans, Rennard cautions that it remains to be seen whether one would even absorb the substances that appeared to have beneficial effects in the lab.

The researchers did not actually isolate specific substances in soup that might be beneficial, “nor did we show what it would do in a living person, let alone a living person with a cold,” he added.

“Chicken soup might do stuff … but lots more research is required,” Rennard said. “There is some possibility that there is a biochemical or medicinal basis to it … but ‘some,’ ‘suggests’ and ‘possible’ are the key words.”

The scent of soup

The aroma, spices and heat from chicken soup could help clear sinuses and improve symptoms of infection among people with respiratory problems, according to a separate study published in Chest.

“It was fun study we did about 40 years ago in Miami Beach, where there’s a big Jewish population that believes in chicken soup,” said the study’s author, Dr. Kiumars Saketkhoo, a pulmonologist and intensivist for PIH Health. “They call it ‘Jewish penicillin.’ “

In the study, tiny particles meant to mimic a clump of bacteria or viruses were inserted in the noses of 15 healthy volunteers. Researchers measured the activity of the particles when they were inserted before and after cold water, hot water and chicken soup.

Hot chicken soup was more effective than hot water in stimulating something known as the mucociliary transport system, which helps move things along in the upper and lower respiratory tract, allowing the body to rid itself of particles and infection.

“The mucociliary transport system is important for getting rid of every respiratory infection, including colds,” Saketkhoo said. “Whatever can make airways clear up faster may decrease risk of infection or clear an existing infection.”

Sipping hot fluids helps to warm the bottom of your nasal pharynx, which can also help improve symptoms, Saketkhoo explained. This might explain why cold water was least effective in the study. But the study suggested that there’s something in chicken soup that gives it an edge.

Saketkhoo cautioned that his study made no health claims or definitive conclusions about chicken soup, though his community seemed quick to embrace his findings. “I heard there was a product being marketed as ‘Mount Sinai chicken soup’ years ago,” he said.

A bowl of nutrients

Studies aside, experts agree that chicken soup is worth trying you’re when sick and can come in handy when eating a solid meal feels like too much.
“Chicken soup can offer a nutrient-dense food option when someone is struggling with a poor appetite,” said Kristen Smith, a registered dietitian and spokeswoman for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. “It can also help increase hydration during a time when this could be a challenge.”

In case you missed it:   Facebook to launch chat app for kids, with parental controls

Most chicken soups contain ingredients that provide lots of vitamins and minerals, according to Smith. For example, carrots provide your body with vitamin A, a nutrient that plays a role in the immune response, and chicken stock contains zinc, which may help fight a cold when consumed in high amounts. Chicken may help with the repair of body tissue and contains the amino acid cysteine, which some researchers are exploring for improving colds in supplement form, though Smith cautions that “most homemade andWe all know the grandmotherly wisdom of serving chicken soup to someone with a cold, but does this particular meal really have medicinal properties? Could slurping up chicken soup save me a trip to the local pharmacy?

You won’t find studies in humans that prove chicken soup can fight a cold, but there’s enough evidence to make it worth trying.
One study published in the medical journal Chest suggested that chicken soup might have anti-inflammatory effects, which could possibly ease symptoms of upper respiratory tract infections.

Researchers specifically studied the movement of neutrophils — a type of white blood cell — when combined with soup. They found that the movement of neutrophils was reduced in the presence of soup, suggesting a possible anti-inflammatory mechanism that could at least theoretically alleviate cold symptoms. Or not.

“There are substances (in chicken soup) that could affect cells in the body, that could potentially have medicinal effects, but whether they are good or bad for you, we didn’t test,” said study author Dr. Stephen Rennard, Larson professor of medicine at the University of Nebraska Medical Center in Omaha.
Because the study was done in a laboratory and not in humans, Rennard cautions that it remains to be seen whether one would even absorb the substances that appeared to have beneficial effects in the lab.

The researchers did not actually isolate specific substances in soup that might be beneficial, “nor did we show what it would do in a living person, let alone a living person with a cold,” he added.

“Chicken soup might do stuff … but lots more research is required,” Rennard said. “There is some possibility that there is a biochemical or medicinal basis to it … but ‘some,’ ‘suggests’ and ‘possible’ are the key words.”

The scent of soup

The aroma, spices and heat from chicken soup could help clear sinuses and improve symptoms of infection among people with respiratory problems, according to a separate study published in Chest.

“It was fun study we did about 40 years ago in Miami Beach, where there’s a big Jewish population that believes in chicken soup,” said the study’s author, Dr. Kiumars Saketkhoo, a pulmonologist and intensivist for PIH Health. “They call it ‘Jewish penicillin.’ “

In the study, tiny particles meant to mimic a clump of bacteria or viruses were inserted in the noses of 15 healthy volunteers. Researchers measured the activity of the particles when they were inserted before and after cold water, hot water and chicken soup.

Hot chicken soup was more effective than hot water in stimulating something known as the mucociliary transport system, which helps move things along in the upper and lower respiratory tract, allowing the body to rid itself of particles and infection.

“The mucociliary transport system is important for getting rid of every respiratory infection, including colds,” Saketkhoo said. “Whatever can make airways clear up faster may decrease risk of infection or clear an existing infection.”

Sipping hot fluids helps to warm the bottom of your nasal pharynx, which can also help improve symptoms, Saketkhoo explained. This might explain why cold water was least effective in the study. But the study suggested that there’s something in chicken soup that gives it an edge.

In case you missed it:   The 9 Stages Of What Happens To Your Body When You Quit Smoking

Saketkhoo cautioned that his study made no health claims or definitive conclusions about chicken soup, though his community seemed quick to embrace his findings. “I heard there was a product being marketed as ‘Mount Sinai chicken soup’ years ago,” he said.

A bowl of nutrients

Studies aside, experts agree that chicken soup is worth trying you’re when sick and can come in handy when eating a solid meal feels like too much.
“Chicken soup can offer a nutrient-dense food option when someone is struggling with a poor appetite,” said Kristen Smith, a registered dietitian and spokeswoman for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. “It can also help increase hydration during a time when this could be a challenge.”

Most chicken soups contain ingredients that provide lots of vitamins and minerals, according to Smith. For example, carrots provide your body with vitamin A, a nutrient that plays a role in the immune response, and chicken stock contains zinc, which may help fight a cold when consumed in high amounts. Chicken may help with the repair of body tissue and contains the amino acid cysteine, which some researchers are exploring for improving colds in supplement form, though Smith cautions that “most homemade and canned varieties would probably not provide adequate amounts to offer benefits.”

There is also the notion that collagen from bone broth or stock can help with healing, “but the current scientific evidence to support this theory is lacking,” Smith said.
Of course, the environment in which chicken soup is often eaten helps, too.

“My wife (who prepared the soup for the study) makes the point that when you are feeling ill, if someone is taking care of you, that tender loving care is not a placebo effect,” Rennard said. “There are clearly beneficial effects of that. So if someone is sitting there and making you chicken soup, it may make you feel better … but whether it has to do with contents of the chicken soup may be irrelevant.”

Saketkhoo said, “does it cure the cold? Of course not. But does it help people with a cold feel better? I think it does … and so that’s why we give hot fluids, including chicken soup, to people with colds.”

The best treatment for the common cold, according to Saketkhoo, is good nutrition, enough bed rest and hot fluids. “And if you like chicken soup, then let it be chicken soup,” he added.[CNN]
canned varieties would probably not provide adequate amounts to offer benefits.”

There is also the notion that collagen from bone broth or stock can help with healing, “but the current scientific evidence to support this theory is lacking,” Smith said.
Of course, the environment in which chicken soup is often eaten helps, too.

“My wife (who prepared the soup for the study) makes the point that when you are feeling ill, if someone is taking care of you, that tender loving care is not a placebo effect,” Rennard said. “There are clearly beneficial effects of that. So if someone is sitting there and making you chicken soup, it may make you feel better … but whether it has to do with contents of the chicken soup may be irrelevant.”

Saketkhoo said, “does it cure the cold? Of course not. But does it help people with a cold feel better? I think it does … and so that’s why we give hot fluids, including chicken soup, to people with colds.”

The best treatment for the common cold, according to Saketkhoo, is good nutrition, enough bed rest and hot fluids. “And if you like chicken soup, then let it be chicken soup,” he added.[CNN]

41 COMMENTS

  1. Insufficient funds dapoxetine duralast JPMorgan Chase and Citigroup Inc providesimilar commodity trading figures to the Fed and the SEC. Butlike Goldman, both banks warn investors in their SEC filingsthat the figures don’t fully represent their performance becausethey exclude earnings on interest, an “integral” part of tradingrevenue.

  2. I don’t like pubs isotretinoin online pharmacy
    So we already knew what had happened as the television news cameras followed the somewhat forlorn journey of the previously all-important piece of paper, in a Jaguar from the hospital to the palace. It was framed there and carried out to the easel by a footman, Badar Azim, and the Queen’s press secretary Ailsa Anderson, who brought a dignity to the moment that was remarkable, in the circumstances.

  3. How much were you paid in your last job? will i get pregnant on clomid Logan said he was trying to “redeem myself” after giving up a sac fly to Mauer and a home run by Morneau on July 4 in Minneapolis. Friday night, he struck out Chris Parmelee, then caught Mauer looking at strike three. Morneau was punched out on a checked swing by third base umpire Kerwin Danley, prompting the first baseman to slam his bat down and fire his helmet toward the Twins dugout.

  4. Incorrect PIN name of viagra tablets Barns expressed dismay after some CCAMLR member countries suggested that the proposed protection in the area come to an end after a number of years. “It’s like creating a national park,” Barnes said, “and it shouldn’t suddenly come to a halt. So that’s one of the really contentious issues that remain.”

  5. Lost credit card paxil cr medscape The SEC settlement said it “may have collateral consequencesunder federal or state law and the rules and regulations ofself-regulatory organizations, licensing boards, and otherregulatory organizations.”

  6. Jonny was here sg calando pris EMPEA said its 2013 survey showed 36 percent of investorsdid not plan to increase or decrease investments, up from 17percent last year, a sign that “an increasing number ofinstitutional investors are reaching their target level ofexposure”.

  7. I’m a trainee cytotec online forum Still, there are no illusions the work is easy or success guaranteed. “College is not for everyone,” says Dean’s president, Paula Rooney. She recounts difficult conversations with parents up front about what’s achievable. Still, she says, Dean is full of students on whom the system would once have given up.

  8. I’m sorry, I didn’t catch your name get effexor cheap In Canada, only two railroad companies are authorized to runone-person train crews: MMA and the Quebec North Shore andLabrador Railway. The vast majority of U.S. rail companies donot use one-person crews, the Federal Railroad Administrationsaid, calling the practice “very rare.”

  9. Is this a temporary or permanent position? revatio traitement World oil prices rose more than 1 percent on speculation that Libyan crude experts would not quickly return to normal after weeks of disruption. Able to supply about 2 percent of world demand, and also a big supplier of gas to Europe, Libya’s six million people can look forward to considerable prosperity, but rivalries over control of resources has hampered investment.

  10. I came here to work viagra in canada without prescription The price of foreign property can seem especially attractive when exchange rates favour the currency of the prospective buyer. Returning to a dreary British summer is another motivator, as travellers seek to spend more time in their favourite sun-drenched destinations. For others, buying overseas is seen as an investment, as undervalued property carries the potential to appreciate substantially over time.

  11. Please wait cozaar 100 mg daily The rally included speeches from Sarah Palin, a hero of the Tea Party movement and former Republican governor of Alaska, andTed Cruz, a freshman Republican senator who has crusaded againstObama’s healthcare law.

  12. How do you know each other? xm viagra commercial MoPub automates buying and selling mobile ads, part of a movement in the digital ad industry towards “programmatic advertising,” or the computerized buying and selling. This deal means Twitter is moving into being a middle man for ad sales across the mobile landscape, not just sellers of ads on its own properties.

  13. Yes, I love it! lisinopril 10 mg tablet lupin I witnessed exactly this recently when I went to a film screening and sat next to a feminist who was a big voice in women’s rights. She was quite beautiful, a suave dresser and an independent person. Her tough thinking was never out of place or wasted on bluster.

  14. International directory enquiries skelaxin gabapentin The analyst did not expect the acquisition to impact Baidu’sA3/A rating but did express concern that the “acquisition paceshould alarm investors on the company’s aggressive growthstrategy, which comes with execution risk and rising leverage,which could threaten the ratings in a longer term.”

  15. I can’t get a signal effects of taking too much dilantin
    NFL commissioner Roger Goodell has gone on record to say that one of the league’s goals is to have a team make its home in the UK, but no firm timetable of when a team would move there, or if it would be an expansion franchise, has been made public.

  16. Your cash is being counted viagra pills oline A group that has adopted the name of the Egyptian movement that paved the way for the military ouster of Islamist President Mohammed Morsi hopes to stage nonviolent protests in nine areas of the country, with the largest expected in Manama, in a new push to persuade the government to grant greater political freedom in the country and to enact a new constitution.

  17. Have you got a telephone directory? what is amoxicillin trihydrate 500mg used for ** Loblaw Cos Ltd, Canada’s largest food retailer,will buy Shoppers Drug Mart Corp, the country’s biggestpharmacy chain, for C$12.4 billion ($11.9 billion) to bulk upagainst intensifying competition from U.S. retail giants as wellas from consolidating local rivals.

  18. Who do you work for? pristiq x venlafaxina “To my teammates, past and present, I appreciate you guys. The Lord has blessed me with a big family and all these men have been part of my family. I thank you – every one if you guys individually – for what you have meant to me. I love you guys. You are special to me and my family.

  19. The line’s engaged asacol price walmart Under current practice, brokers give traders as much asthree days to pony up the money to make a margin call, eventhough the money is actually due on the same day the call ismade. The broker covers any shortfall during that time, and itis “totally appropriate” to use its own capital to do so,Gensler said.

  20. Do you need a work permit? uk viagra trial Their struggle with the Syria issue began in early May, when Kerry traveled to Moscow, met with Putin and pressed the Russians to become more involved in efforts to end Syria’s civil war, which has killed more than 100,000 people.

  21. A jiffy bag prevacid fastab 15mg The Boy Scouts of America organization said they published their height/weight requirements for this year’s national gathering years in advance so scouts would have a reason to work toward healthy goals.

  22. Insert your card mail order for viagra
    Of course, there are those who will argue that my theory is misguided, on the grounds that, for example, Mr Browne is still alive. To them I say: wake up, sheeple. How do you know Mr Browne is still alive? Do you know what he looks like? Does anyone? Does his family?

  23. I like watching football kamagra jel Cinema audiences were terrified and delighted in equal amount and Michael Myers, with his battered white facemask became a pop culture icon, preceding the likes of Jason Voorhees, the hockey-masked brute from the Friday the 13th films and Freddie Krueger of the Nightmare on Elm Street franchise.

  24. I can’t get through at the moment slimfast uk reviews Simple: It’s a tax on carbon dioxide (CO2) huffed into the atmosphere when we burn coal, oil, natural gas, gasoline, and any other carbon-based fuel. CO2 is the biggest contributor to climate change, and putting a tax on it is one way to encourage people to spew a little less of it. There are different ways to structure these taxes, but the generally accepted method is to collect them at the source: The coal company or the oil company pays based on the amount of CO2 their product will create.

  25. I stay at home and look after the children efectos secundarios de paxil cr 25 mg You might also consider adjusting your home’s layout during the summer months. For instance, if you have a basement, consider moving your couch and TV down there. Since heat rises, basements are always naturally cooler, allowing you to set the thermostat a little higher while you’re relaxing in front of the TV.

  26. I want to make a withdrawal singulair baby msd online “I don’t know. It wasn’t enough, you know? I wish I could stop them all there,” Lundqvist said Saturday, nevertheless in a better mood than he’d been in all week. “But what I can take out of it: It was less thinking and more reacting on my part, and that’s what I need… That’s when you make better decisions… But it was also because it was probably so intense I didn’t have time to think. It was a lot of chances.”

  27. Which year are you in? effects of quitting propecia It’s time to think again about why universities bother with ‘freshers’ periods at all. What would be the problem with having everyone start full-time lectures and teaching on day one of university? Clearly we avoid mass confusion and social voids by having a settling-in period, however, if we’re having this ‘Week 0’ before term starts, we need to look at the impact of the activities we’re providing.

  28. Good crew it’s cool 🙂 bactrim antibiotic online Buckie Shipyard, which provided build and repair services for clients like RNLI, the MoD and Orkney Ferries, had recently diversified into the offshore wind industry, offering engineering, repair and maintenance services.

  29. What sort of music do you like? aciphex coupons online After the Dale Farm evictions the Left-leaning press decried the victimisation of an already marginalised group, while the Right-wing press applauded the restoration of law and order. Both views were only partial truths, reflecting the stereotypes on the one hand of Travellers as anti-social reprobates, on the other as colourful reminders of a sentimentalised rural past.

  30. How do you do? is reglan used to increase milk supply “The defacement of a public statue with words and symbols of hate is an act of intimidation that affects our entire community,” Neuer said. “It is that much worse that the attack targeted the statue of Jackie Robinson, an iconic sports legend and an African-American hero who helped to integrate Major League Baseball.”

  31. My battery’s about to run out propranolol tablets bp 10mg The Rangers captain will miss the next three-to-four weeks with a broken left thumb, the team announced Thursday afternoon, after blocking a shot on the final shift of Wednesday night’s 2-0 win in Washington.

  32. Do you know the address? albuterol tablets online australia “We continue to pursue accountability and recovery in thewake of billions of dollars in sales of faulty securities thatled to the collapse of several corporate credit unions andhanded the industry the costly bill of paying for the losses,”NCUA Board Chairman Debbie Matz said.

  33. I’ll call back later price for lexapro at walmart (Additional reporting by Erika Solomon, Stephen Kalin and Dominic Evans in Beirut, Khaled Yacoub Oweis in Amman, Dasha Afanasieva in Istanbul and Asma Alsharif at the United Nations.; Writing by Will Dunham; editing by Christopher Wilson)

  34. I’m unemployed cheap nolvadex for sale The man, who asked that his identity be kept secret out of concern for his safety, made the claim in an interview with WFXT television in Boston, and said he recognized Hernandez as the man who fatally shot two of his friends in July 2012 after the former NFL star was arrested this past June for the murder of Odin Lloyd. 

  35. I’ll put her on atenolol (tenormin) 25 mg House Republicans are now proceeding with a legislative approach attempting to push forth piecemeal funding bills, which would reopen popular sectors of the federal government including parks, national memorials and the Department of Veterans Affairs until a more long-term budget agreement can be reached. Still, republicans “continue to seek concessions on the Affordable Care Act in exchange for passage of the funding bill.”

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here